wiqqi
Book

Attachment and Loss

Also known as Attachment and Loss trilogy, Attachment (Attachment and Loss, vol. 1), Separation: Anxiety and Anger, Separation: Anxiety and Anger (vol. 2), Loss: Sadness and Depression, Loss: Sadness and Depression (vol. 3), Attachment, Separation, Loss

John Bowlby's three-volume founding statement of attachment theory (1969, 1973, 1980)

At a glance

Also on this page: Key facts · Links · Sources · Related pages

Why it matters

Key facts

Author
John Bowlby1
Volumes
Attachment (1969), Separation: Anxiety and Anger (1973), Loss: Sadness and Depression (1980)1
Revised
Attachment, revised 1982 to add newer research1
Publishers
Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis (London); Basic Books (New York)1
Pages
Attachment, 464 (Basic Books, 2nd edition)3
Pages
Separation, 480 (Basic Books)5
Pages
Loss, 496 (Basic Books)6
ISBN
Attachment 9780465005437 (Basic Books)3
ISBN
Separation 9780465097166 (Basic Books)5
ISBN
Loss 9780465042388 (Basic Books)6
Influence
Attachment theory became a dominant approach to understanding early social development1

What it argues

  1. Attachment is an instinct for protection2

    Attachment behavior aims at closeness to a caregiver; its evolutionary job is protecting the infant from danger, not feeding.

  2. Separation explains fear2

    Children fear both cues to danger and the absence of an attachment figure; separation and the threat of it breed anxiety.

  3. Loss explains grief and defence2

    Bowlby explains mourning in young children and how painful information gets excluded from awareness.

Key ideas

  1. Behavioral systems instead of drives2

    Bowlby replaced Freud's psychic energy with goal-corrected control systems borrowed from ethology and cybernetics.

  2. Secure base and safe haven2

    A child explores from the attachment figure and returns to it for comfort; how well that works depends on the carer's sensitivity.

  3. Internal working models2

    Children form models of self and attachment figure: valued and reliable when needs were met, unworthy when bids were rejected.

  4. Patterns pass down the generations2

    Bowlby held that family micro-culture passes on mental health and ill health at least as much as genes do.

  5. Defensive exclusion2

    Information too painful to think about is kept out of awareness, which splits working models and blocks their updating.

Examples from the book

  1. Ploughing Freud's field2

    In the preface Bowlby wrote that his field "was no less than the one Freud had started tilling sixty years earlier".

  2. The dog between mother and child2

    Fleeing danger and fleeing to an attachment figure are separate systems, visible when a fierce dog comes between a mother and her child.

  3. Smooth and troubled pairs2

    When interaction between a couple runs smoothly each takes pleasure in the other; persistent conflict brings anxiety and unhappiness (vol. 1, p. 242).

Criticism and limits

  1. Rejected by psychoanalysts1

    Bowlby rejected psychoanalytic accounts of attachment, and psychoanalysts in turn rejected his theory.

  2. Slow uptake for volumes 2 and 32

    Separation and Loss made less impact than Attachment at first, partly because supporting studies lagged behind.

  3. Wider objections to the theory4

    Critics fault attachment theory on temperament, measurement, neglect of social complexity and mother-blaming.

Connections

Sources

  1. John Bowlby (Wikipedia) (opens en.wikipedia.org)
  2. Bretherton I. The origins of attachment theory: John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth, Developmental Psychology 1992 (opens psychology.sunysb.edu)
  3. Attachment by John Bowlby (Basic Books / Hachette) (opens hachettebookgroup.com)
  4. Attachment theory (Wikipedia) (opens en.wikipedia.org)
  5. Separation by John Bowlby (Basic Books / Hachette) (opens hachettebookgroup.com)
  6. Loss by John Bowlby (Basic Books / Hachette) (opens hachettebookgroup.com)

Last checked against its sources today

Is something on this page wrong or out of date? Tell us

How recent

The line under a date fills as time passes: empty when new, then one equal share each for a day, a week, a month and a year. For episodes and other items it is full at 2 years; for "last checked", at a year. A striped line means the date is known only to the month or year.